Sunday, 31 January 2021

Opposed Rolls

  • I'm not a fan of opposed rolls.
  • Especially opposed dice pool rolls!
  • The worst example has to be Exalted, where after countless rolls the result is that nothing happens.
    • To give White Wolf their due, they did fix this in NWoD/Chronicles of Darkness, making all modifiers apply to the pool before rolling.
  • Things have bogged down when I played Fate due to opposed Attack / Defense rolls too.
  • Conversely, I love the fact that in DCC there is a fixed DC for the Thief's Sneak Silently skill based on conditions, not an opposed perception roll.
  • I think there are two basic problems with opposed rolls:
    • Increasing the number of times dice need to be rolled.
    • The rule of averages meaning as a net result nothing happens.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Evolved forms of D&D variants

 - I wonder if certain versions of D&D represent the evolved forms of certain approaches to the game. - These forms developed over exten...